Replacement Garage Doors: Amarr Heritage vs Lincoln vs Hillcrest
These three Amarr collections cover the same ground: a traditional-looking insulated steel door. The look is where they split. Heritage and Lincoln are traditional panel doors; Hillcrest is a carriage-house design. Underneath, the numbers are where the choice gets made.
Planning a garage door replacement? This page helps you narrow the choice. For how a replacement works from measure to install, see our garage door replacement service. If a broken spring is what brought you here, start with garage door spring repair.
Side by side
| Heritage | Lincoln | Hillcrest | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Look | Short, long, flush, ribbed; carriage options too | Raised panel | Bead board and recessed carriage house |
| 1000 (single layer, no insulation) | 24 ga | 25 ga | 25 ga |
| 2000 (R-6.64) | 24 ga outer | 25 ga | 25 ga |
| 3000 (R-9.05) | 24 outer / 27 inner | 25 ga | 25 ga |
| 3138 (R-6.48, 27/27 ga) | not offered | offered | offered |
| Paint warranty (1000 / 2000 / 3000) | Lifetime on all | 15 yr / 25 yr / Lifetime | 15 yr / 25 yr / Lifetime |
| Workmanship warranty (1000 / 2000 / 3000) | 3 yr / 5 yr / Lifetime | 1 yr / 2 yr / Lifetime | 1 yr / 2 yr / 3 yr |
The short version
- Heritage has the heaviest outer steel (24 gauge on every model) and the longest paint warranty on every tier. It is the one to choose when you plan to stay and want the longest coverage.
- Lincoln gives you the same R-values with lighter steel and a shorter warranty on the lower tiers, with a Lifetime workmanship warranty on the 3000.
- Hillcrest matches Lincoln’s numbers but is a carriage-house design, and its 3000 has a 3-year workmanship warranty rather than Lifetime.
- If you are weighing the top tier of each: Heritage HR3000 and Lincoln LI3000 both carry R-9.05 and a Lifetime workmanship warranty; the Heritage has the heavier outer skin.
The collections covered here
Amarr Heritage Collection
The Amarr Heritage Collection is a heavy-gauge 24-gauge steel garage door line in traditional raised-panel and carriage house designs.
View detailsAmarr Lincoln Collection
The Amarr Lincoln Collection is a traditional raised-panel steel garage door in four models from a single-layer entry door to a three-layer insulated build with R-9.05.
View detailsAmarr Hillcrest
The Amarr Hillcrest is a steel carriage house garage door available in four insulation tiers, from a single-layer panel up to a three-layer build with R-9.05.
View detailsRelated services
Related questions
More door guides
Want help choosing the right door?
We measure the opening, talk through how you use the garage, and give you a flat-rate quote for the door that fits.